I have previoulsy had two Maru noseclips which work well provided I could stop them sliding off my nose. I read the review on this one that said it was a bit too grippy so I thought I'd give it a try. The hoop is a little smaller than the Maru and it fits really snugly round the end of my nose. I have used it on two swims so far and it has stayed exactly where I placed it throughout the sessions. I needed a new clip because I lost one of the rubber pads of my last Maru in the pool - this one has the benefit that the pads are moulded into the frame so it shouldn't fail in the same way. Only 4 stars because it doesn't feel that comfortable to wear, but maybe that's asking too much from something that pushes your nose into an unnatural shape!